Limestone Edge

The stay was great, and we were surprised by the location it was very convenient. We stayed here on the fourth and could see the fireworks from the pier! Was truly an awesome spot.
Our few complaints I point to the management company. Some of the towels in the bathrooms were musty and not very well cleaned, additionally we couldn’t find extra towels. Also, there is a cabin/boat house in back and we were unable to access it. It appears it had been dead locked. The code we provided appears correct but the door was deadlocked. We contacted the company for two days and were not able to get in.
I would stay again, as I believe these are some simple fixes!

Will - Posted: 7/5/2026

The house worked out great for all 11 of us ages 15-78. The small cottage in the back worked out great for one of the couples. The fire pit was surrounded by lots of comfy chairs either a view that was amazing.

bonnie - Posted: 6/26/2026

Good locationBathtub and coffee maker weren’t clean

Judith - Posted: 10/9/2025

Hello Judith, We truly appreciate you sharing your feedback. We're very sorry to hear about the cleanliness issues you encountered with the bathtub and coffee maker—this certainly isn’t the experience we want for our guests. Our team has been notified so we can make sure it’s taken care of right away. We hope you’ll consider staying with us again for a much better visit next time. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Nice house, roomy and well-appointed with great views and lake frontage. Close to everything in Baileys Harbor and in a convenient location to visit anywhere on the Door County peninsula. Only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is privacy: there’s a wine bar on one side that is sometimes busy, but even when not, there are some moms — at least when we were there - who visit the wine bar after school or day care as a playground, so it was loudest in the late afternoon. In the other side is a small parking lot, which allows in a lot of road noise. Great property, but you should be aware of these issues before booking.

Jamie - Posted: 8/24/2025

Hello Jamie, Thank you for your review and for highlighting the beautiful views, lake frontage, and convenient location of the home. We also appreciate your feedback regarding privacy and outside activity, and while some of these factors are outside our control, we’ll continue looking for ways to enhance the overall guest experience. We’re glad you enjoyed your stay and would be happy to host you again in the future. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Incredible location, roomy home, a few quibbles. Pros:- incredible location- spacious home- responsive management- working a/cCons:- very stingy on household items- not as well-cleaned as expected- very unpleasant tap waterNote:- no reserved parking spots- spotty internet at timesThe location of this home is amazing. Near everything in Bailey’s Harbor. We walked for coffee, lunch, and dinner multiple times. It’s quite walkable to Ridges beach. The bedrooms and bathrooms were just right for our family of 5 adults, 2 elementary kids, and 2 teenagers. The appliances are mostly good with two exceptions:. The touchless kitchen faucet is unreliable, and the drawer/beverage fridges don’t hold the indicated temperature. The tap water is very unpleasant. They have a reverse osmosis tap in the kitchen that is essential for drinking. You come out of the shower with a distinct aquarium-chemical smell. Not sure if this is a well water issue. The household goods were very stingy for what you pay. Not enough toilet paper for more than a couple of days. No facial tissue. One dishwasher packet. (Rinse aid was empty in the dishwasher). Hotel-sized samples of soap/shampoo. We had to buy more of all of those. The cleaning crew missed things, such as an advil on the floor near the bed, a wet and very caked coffee maker, left-behind food. Again, for what you pay, you expect more. We did have very good interactions with the managers. Responsive and very friendly.

stephen - Posted: 7/28/2025

We're truly sorry that parts of your stay didn’t meet expectations. We’re glad you enjoyed the location and that the home worked well for your group, but we’ll be reviewing your feedback closely with our team to ensure improvements moving forward.

Simple Life Rentals staff

The location of this house is perfect for a group with different needs. We were close enough to drive to all towns if we wanted, or walk around Bailey’s Harbor. We were concerned being close to the winery and main road would be noisy, but it wasn’t at all! It’s a quiet town, which we loved. We loved the fire pit as well. Lots of comfortable seating for a big group- we used it every night! Sitting outside in the evenings and looking out over the lake was definitely a highlight! There were lots of extra blankets, pillows, etc. The house was very well stocked! We were also concerned street parking would be an issue because we had 4 cars, but using the lot next door was great! We never had a problem. While there was plenty of space and a fully stocked kitchen, the home was not as clean as it could have been. It felt like it had been cleaned weeks ago, so dead bugs started accumulating. There were spider webs in the corners and dead bugs in window sills. The bugs didn’t bother most of the people in our group, but for the amount we were paying, it felt like more attention could have been given to the home. The house also didn’t provide any outdoor games like corn hole or any water toys. We would have liked to paddle board off the dock.

Emily - Posted: 7/18/2025

Hello Emily, Thank you for sharing your experience — we’re so glad you enjoyed the location, lake views, fire pit, and overall space for your group. It’s wonderful to hear the home worked well for your stay and that parking and amenities met your needs. We’re sorry to hear that the cleanliness did not fully meet expectations and appreciate you bringing that to our attention so we can address it with our team. We value your feedback and hope to welcome you back again for another great stay in the future. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Eight old friends got together for a beautiful visit at this spacious and well appointed VRBO. Great location as well.

Rusty - Posted: 6/6/2025

Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear your group of friends had a beautiful visit and enjoyed the space and location. There’s nothing better than reconnecting and making memories in a comfortable setting. We'd love to welcome you all back anytime! 😊

Simple Life Rentals staff

Overall, the owners have done a nice job modernizing this old home, and you can tell they enoy this property. The home itself is very comfortable, and the grounds offer plenty of outdoor space. What's not readily apparent from the listing is that a wine bar with outdoor space for customers borders the property to the south. During quiet evenings, noise from the bar can be heard. Bordering the north side of the property is a public parking lot and another home's yard. During busy business hours, the lot may be full. We also had an unfortunate run-in with the neighbor over, of all things, parking. The property has a garage with a grass "driveway" in front of it. The check-in email from the property manager said this space could fit a vehicle and trailer if necessary, or the public parking lot or street parking could be used. We chose to park one of our three vehicles on this grassy area because the street and lot parking filled up during the busy holiday weekend. The neighbor was upset that we were parked on the lawn and was seen taking photos of our vehicle. When confronted, he became confrontational, saying he knows the owners and that they wouldn't want a vehicle on the grass. I offered to show him the email that said we could park there, but he proceeded to argue that it was rude to park on the grass and that it was damaging it. He then apparently texted the photo to the owners (we didn’t hear from them about the issue). Not the experience we expected to have.

Derrick - Posted: 6/5/2025

Hello Derrick, Thank you for your thoughtful review! We're so glad you found the home comfortable and enjoyed the outdoor space. We appreciate your feedback about the surrounding area and are sorry to hear about the brief parking concern during your stay. Your notes help us continue to improve the guest experience, and we’re happy to hear you still enjoyed the property overall. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff