Sunset Shores - Tiger Lily Cabin #5

No more than two people and make it a short stay. Cost does not reflect quality for this listing.

John - Posted: 7/7/2026

This cabin's location is amazing - right on the lake, and centrally located within an easy drive of everything Door County has to offer. The property management was extremely responsive and helpful.

Susan - Posted: 7/6/2026

The location was beautiful with the lake and very peaceful. The cabin was very cozy and nicely updated. We definitely enjoyed this place to celebrate our anniversary!

Grace - Posted: 10/5/2025

Hello Grace,
Thank you so much for sharing your experience with us! We’re thrilled to know you had a wonderful and peaceful stay and that the cabin made your anniversary celebration special. It’s always a joy to host moments like these. We’d love to welcome you back anytime for another relaxing getaway by the lake!
Warm regards,
The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Place was nice and cozy location was great!!!!! There were other people’s half full monster cans on the table and a news paper scattered about the table as well. Batteries in the bedroom tv remote for Roku were dead, luckily we had the Roku app on our phone to be able to watch the tv.

Derek - Posted: 10/1/2025

Hello Derek, Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re very sorry to hear about the cleaning oversight and the issue with the remote batteries — that’s certainly not the experience we want our guests to have. We truly appreciate you bringing this to our attention so we can make sure it’s promptly addressed with our team. We’re grateful you still enjoyed the cozy home and great location, and we hope to have the chance to host you again for a much smoother stay. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

So for starters. The place was very expensive for the stay. I guess being a holiday weekend puts it at that price. The cottage was VERY small which is was ok for just 2 of us. However, a few things. If you rent, I highly recommend against the tiger lily cabin. My 10 heat old son was excited and went out on the pier while I was unpacking. 30 seconds later I hear a grown women yelling at him and SWEARING non stop to get his ass off her property or else... they don't warn you that the cabin literally is on the private property line! That lady is lucky she stopped when she did and I heard her otherwise it would've escalated. Swearing non stop at a 10 year old is crazy! Also, the lighter for fire lit did not work nor were there any fire starters. Lastly, for the amount I paid, I should have to do the cleaning before I leave

Nichole - Posted: 9/1/2025

Hello Nichole,
Thank you for your feedback. We’re so sorry that parts of your stay were less than what you had hoped for. That is never the experience we want for our guests, and we truly regret that this visit did not feel as smooth or enjoyable as it should have. Please know your comments have been shared with our team so we can address these concerns and make improvements moving forward. We really appreciate you bringing this to our attention and are grateful for the chance to do better.
Warm regards,
The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Celebrated my 70th here and Staci worked with my husband to have a wonderful gift package awaiting us when we arrived! We loved how close the cabin was to the water’s edge and the town of Bailey’s Harbor. Clean and all the amenities you need right there! Perfect for two! Will be coming back!

Virginia - Posted: 8/10/2025

Hello Virginia, Thank you so much for celebrating such a special milestone with us! We’re delighted to hear you enjoyed the cabin, the thoughtful gift, and the beautiful setting in Bailey’s Harbor. It’s wonderful to know everything felt just right for your stay, and we’d be honored to welcome you back anytime! Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Great dog friendly place

Addie - Posted: 7/20/2025

Nothing makes us happier than happy guests and wagging tails. Thanks for the kind words!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We felt this was an expensive stay considering the off time of service and the state of the cabin. Overall the things were clean but we didn’t have enough wash cloths and the main light source did not work for the duration of our trip. Additionally there were games and movies advertised in an office and neither were there. The office was a shed that was locked.

Kaitlyn - Posted: 9/22/2024

Thank you so much for your feedback. We take everything you wrote very seriously and will ensure each item is stocked for future guests. We’d love an opportunity to host you again to show you how responsive we are to ensuring a five star stay.

Simple Life Rentals staff

It's a nice place if you're bringing a boat. Pretty lake. The community felt a bit crowded, but quiet at night.

Jane - Posted: 8/4/2024

Thank you for your feedback. We're glad you enjoyed the beautiful lake setting and found the Sunset Shores community quiet at night. We appreciate you bringing the private concerns to our attention and we will most certainly address accordingly. Your comments are invaluable as we work to improve the comfort for future guests. Thank you again for sharing, and we hope to have the chance to welcome you back!

Simple Life Rentals staff

This cabin is very small but makes good use of the space. It would've been a little more clear if the fire pit with chairs pic was explained that this was the community one & not actually right by the cabin. The only reason this stay wasn't 100% amazing was bc it was so hot at night. The fan helps, but bringing a portable AC unit would be a necessity. This is obviously not really the cabins fault. It is what it is. But if u can't sleep over 80 degrees, you'll struggle. Also it was an invasion of ants. Again, it's a cabin in the woods & on the lake, so it's just the circumstances. They are tiny & don't bite at least. But they were crawling all over the kitchen & on the bedsheets. Those 2 things aside, we really had a good weekend & luckily had awesome neighbors that we made friends with. The communal living is probably awesome (like we had with great neighbors), or awful if you have not awesome people lol. Our kids loved the playground there. It's a great location & beautiful.

Becky - Posted: 7/15/2024

Becky, Thank you for your feedback. We tried our best to be clear that this cabin was one of six with the shared outdoor amenities, but will certainly review and revise. We also will escalate the feedback on the heat and insect concerns to ensure action is taken on both. Overall, we are so glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to have the opportunity to host you again in the future!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Great, quiet location!

Kirsten - Posted: 7/7/2024

Thank you, Kirsten!!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Perfect little get away for my sister, my son, and her two dogs. Close to the beautiful Kangaroo Lake. Lovely and comfortable cottage with everything you need.

Maggie - Posted: 6/16/2024

Thanks for your kind review, Maggie! It was our pleasure to host you and your family!

Simple Life Rentals staff